Author: Marcin Brzezicki
Source: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Volume 603, Issue 2
DOI:10.1088/1757-899X/603/2/022040
Abstract
The use of glass fins constitutes a recently emerging trend in the façade industry. Fins (ribs) could be defined as long glass strips mounted perpendicularly to the surface of the façade. Fins are used as (i) decorative (aesthetical enrichment of the facade), (ii) functional (sunshade) and (iii) structural (stiffening and load-bearing) elements of the facade. The overall trend of using glass fins is a result of the abundance of proper quality glass, that allows for safe use of relatively small elements that are point mounted or fixed in a different way to the surface of the facade. This glass fin trend deserves a review, illustrated with the on-site made photographs showing different areas of application. The given review of the application of glass fins is based on a general morphology study of transparent facades that the author conducted through the year 2017-2019, and including the position of the fin, the orientation of the fin, and the transmissive qualities of the fin – transparent, translucent and screen-printed. Fins could be also addressed as a formal articulation element strategic from the point of the building’s architectural form.
1. Introduction
Contemporary architectural transparency (understood as the optical property of transmitting the light through the material) is constantly being redefined and, over the last decade, new design trends related to transparent façades in architecture have been developed. Those trends are the results of the dynamic technological progress and of the advancement in the field of materials science. Transparency is no longer limited to specific functions (e.g. illumination of the interior) but has become a tool of formal expression itself. Apart from the standard understanding of transparency as the use of light-permeable materials in façade design, one can find other innovative and creative interpretations. Glass fins became one of the elements of this abundant transparency trend around the 1950s and are rapidly developing now.
2. Methodology
This brief overview of the application of glass fins is based on general morphology studies of transparent facades that the author conducted through the year 2015-2017 and published in 2018 [1]. This allowed for the isolation of one of the main trends – a glass fin trend that, as the author believes, deserves a deeper analysis. Trend’s description given in this paper is followed by on-site made photographs showing different areas of application in the completed buildings.
3. Glass fin trend
Glass fins (also called ribs and lamellas) could be defined as long glass strips mounted to the surface of the façade. The fins are mounted in both: horizontal and vertical position and at the different angles in the relation to the façade’s surface (usually perpendicularly). Fins are used as a structural, functional and decorative element of the facade. The occurrence of the glass-fin trend is obviously related to the development in the area of glass fittings, mounting, and lamination. This allowed narrow strips to be manufactured and safely point- or edge-mounted to the façade at a height.
4. Glass fin as a structural element
This short preview offers no space for the detailed presentation of structural characteristics of glass fins, but at least few issues might be discussed. Structural glass fins are mainly the result of the architect´s and their clients´ strive to create so-called all-glass facades. The use of this system dates back to 1950s when fins were used to stabilize shop windows with one of the first application at the Maison de la Radio in Paris (arch. Henry Bernard, 1952-1963) [2]. Glass fins from the structural point of view replace the opaque vertical mullions in classic curtain-wall façade systems.
The successful application of this system in the first buildings – e.g. Willis Faber & Dumas Headquarters by Foster and Partners, where the façade is partially hung from above – using glass fins – facilitated the spread of the system and pushed the technology for the creation of new developments. Glass fins are connected to the façade glazing by the means of patch fittings, corner connections or point mount fittings, available systems are numerous offering the fin height up to 12-15 meters, reaching 18 m is some conceptual proposals [3]. The patch fittings and point-mounting systems were introduced subsequently. Steel plates are also laminated between the layers of glass forming glass fins. Plates are later used to connect elements of the facade and to provide the proper load transfer.
The most challenging aspect of a glass-fin wall “occurs when the span is too great to be accommodated by a single piece fin, and a splice detail must be developed to create a fin comprised of multiple glass pieces” [4]. Initially, longer fins had to be connected by the means of patch plates to fix smaller fins together, but the newest laminated tempered glass fin technology even allows for laminated fins to be produced over 40 feet tall in one piece (e.g. by Sedak).
Structural engineers use glass fins as the means of stiffening the structure. Their orientation is usually perpendicular to the surface of the glazed façade. Fins are used to make glazed walls more rigid, to reduce deflections, and to improve bearing capacity of horizontal loads – they usually “carry the wind positive pressure and suction forces” [5]. Jan Wurm writes, that from the structural point of view, fins are “normally suspended and any movements in the primary structure are accommodated at the bottom support of the fin” [5].
Fins are usually made of laminated glass but might be also monolithic. Besides the structural differences, there are some visual constraints concerning the use of laminated fins as “these systems may seem thicker than monolithic fins when viewed from the inside on an angle or from directly behind even with ultra-clear, low-iron glass” [2]. Even if the interlayer used to laminate the glass is clear, it will still be somewhat visible from inside. This effect could be seen in the Apple Store Boylston Street in Boston (arch. Bohlin Cywinski Jackson, 2008), where glass fins are manufactured from 5 panes of glass with structural interlayer material, visibly affecting the transparency of this element (see Figure 1). In this particular case, the fins are rigidly connected with the beams forming one continuous element (a portal frame). Although a beam looks similar to the fin, it is subjected to bending force and resulting buckling, thus has to be designed differently. The elements are connected by the means of polished stainless steel fittings.
5. Glass fin as a functional element
Functional glass fins are used as a shading elements, thus the fins become louvers. Usually horizontally oriented, they block the sun and allow users of the building for the uninterrupted outside views. Louvers used as a shading require more maintenance, as the horizontal position facilities the dirt accumulation. In some cases, horizontal glass louvers are motorized and adjust to the sunlight angle. One of the most complicated mechanical glass louver retracting systems was developed at the end of the 1990s in Zurich, at the Tamedia Ernst-Nobs Platz Headquarter (arch. Atelier WW, 2001). Opaque glass louvers are motorized using the pantograph systems that lowers them into the correct position by the means of regulating the length of steel cables. The bona fide glass transparent fins are used as a support for a guiding rail for this mechanism, not as a part of the light scattering system (see Figure 2).
Fins for shading are also used in a vertical position, this makes them less prone to the dirt and soiling. External vertical glass fins are also used as a light diffusing element and are therefore called baffles (performing the function of the so-called vertical light shelf). For even more effective light scattering vertical glass, fins are manufactured as translucent elements, e.g. sandblasted or frit-printed as “when they are infused, they can help evenly distribute light without reducing the total amount of light significantly” [4] and might contribute to the overall glare reduction in the office rooms e.g. like in Canada Place at Canary Wharf, (arch. Zeidler Partnership Architects, 2003), see Figure 3.
Sandblasted fins located on the northern façade of Federal Office Building in San Francisco (arch. Morphosis, 2007) are used as light redirecting devices (see Figure 4a) while screen-printed fins on the western façade of INES – French National Solar Energy Institute (arch. Atelier Michel Rémon + Agence Frédéric Nicolas, 2013) are used as both: light redirection (during the peak hours of the day) and shading device (at the afternoon – see Figure 4b). Glass fins in INES could be pivoted around the vertical axis by the means of electric actuators (one actuator controls four fins at one floor height). A similar system was applied in Galizia Fashion Plaza building, in the German city of Metzingen.
Glass fins are also used as a PV cells carrier producing the so-called shadovoltaic element. PV cells are usually laminated between two panes of glass what facilitates the process of production and protect the cells from the influence of weather. The installation orientation might vary depending on the prospected outcome. In the Swiss Tech Convention Center (arch. Richter Dahl Rocha & Associés, 2014) dyed transparent cells are installed in a form of glass lamellas in a vertical orientation and slanted at a slightly oblique angle, allowing for easy airflow but still remaining visible from the inside of the building (see Figure 5).
Good ventilation results in the surface temperature drop of PV cell which makes them more effective in terms of energy production [6]. In Merck’s Innovation Center in Darmstadt (arch. Henn Architekten, 2015), the company Colt installed a total number of 74 photovoltaic fins for generating electrical energy. Some of them are static and located perpendicularly to the surface of the façade, but 17 fins are vertically pivoted to follow the sun and increase the energy gain [7]. The rotatable solar cells generate electricity and at the same time provide shading and heat reflection.
Efficiencies beyond 12 percent can be reproduced in the laboratory, while the range from 2 to 3 percent is achievable in large-scale applications. A similar application of glass fins could be observed at the headquarters of private equity company Istituto Atesino di Sviluppo (arch. Renzo Piano Building Workshop, 2013) located in Le Albere district in Trento. In this case, the PV elements laminated between panes of glass are forming horizontal louvers, that both protect the building from the sun and generate electricity (see Figure 6).
6. Glass fin as a decorative element
The glass fins are used also as an eye-catching element. Fins (usually in this case called lamellas) that are located perpendicularly to the façade allow to change the façade appearance depending on the viewer’s position. The buildings seem massive, form the oblique perspective and light and airy if viewed frontally. This is also frequently connected with the experiments with the material itself; the decorative fins are sandblasted, pattern decorated, painted, and coated in special coatings (e.g. the spectral selective coatings) like in an art installation called Dichroic Light Field in New York (arch. James Carpenter, 1995) – see Figure 7a. G fins are also frequently used as a substitution of sculptural decoration that flat glazed facades lack.
Many efforts in this field lead to the creation of very impressing cases of application of glass fins as strictly decorative elements. One of the most impressive cases of the decorative fins´ application is the W16 building in Brussels (arch. Conix RDBM Architects, 2009), where glass fins are twisted around the vertical axis and edge mounted to the floor plates projecting from the building. The glass in the fins is cold bend, offering an unprecedented amount of distorted reflections when viewed from the oblique angle (see Figure 7b).
7. Discussion
The most common placement pattern is defined by the fin’s function: structural fins are most commonly located inside, while the shading fins are placed outside, to prevent the sunlight from the penetration of the building’s interior. This external location usually causes increased soiling, dirt accumulation, and the higher maintenance effort but – simultaneously – some of those fins are frequently used as decorative elements of the façade. Structural fins are usually vertical, while functional ones are adjusted according to the Sun’s path and building geometry. With the South facing facades, fin’s location is horizontal, while East and West facades are most effectively shaded by vertical fins, like in the case of Federal Office Building in San Francisco (arch. Morphosis, 2007).
In selected cases of adaptive facades, glass fins could be motorized to follow the Sun path or provide the shading or daylight scattering on user’s demand. In this way, an adaptive façade is able to “change its functions, features or behavior over time, in response to transient performance requirements and boundary conditions” [8] by the adjustment of a single element. In this way, fins help to avoid the interior overheating and protect the users from the glare, like in the case of the Oval Offices in Cologne (arch. Sauerbruch and Hutton, 2010) – see Figure 8 – where lacquered glass fins are motorized to provide daylight’s regulation to the building’s users.
8. Conclusion
The fins have undoubtedly become parts of the contemporary glazed facades, fulfilling many functions and offering multiple visual effects. Those could be used as structural, functional and decorative elements. As the structural glazing develops over time, the fins are systematically included in the facades as a load-bearing element, allowing for the replacement of the non-transparent mullions. At the same time, the fins are shading and energy harvesting elements, while simultaneously producing an interesting optical outcome. The aesthetical role of the glass fins cannot be underestimated as fins are frequently used as a sculptural element of the façade, emphasizing its rhythm and defining proportions.
Acknowledgment(s)
This paper was funded by the Polish National Science Centre grants entitled: “New trends in the architecture of transparent facades – formal experiments, technological innovations”, ref. no. 2014/15/B/ST8/00191 and by the grant entitled: “Glass fins (ribs) as a decorative and structural element of glazed facades. Case-study analysis”, ref. no: S80401-0067-10-K0106.
References
[1] M. Brzezicki, Studies on glass facades morphologies, Engineered transparency 2018: glass in architecture and structural engineering, eds.: Jens Schneider, Bernhard Weller. Berlin WileyBlackwell/Ernst & Sohn, cop. 2018. pp. 153-160.
[2] C. Hein, The Capital of Europe: Architecture and Urban Planning for the European Union, Greenwood Publishing Group, 2004.
[3] J. Kooymans, J. Schneider and H. Techen, Long span glass fin design, Challenging Glass: Conference on Architectural and Structural Applications of Glass; ed. F. Bos, Ch. Louter; F. Veer, Faculty of Architecture, Delft University of Technology, IOS Press, 2008.
[4] Enclos Corp, Glass Fin [online] Service and Technology, 2019 [accessed 1.03.2019], Available at: http://www.enclos.com/service-and-technology/technology/structural-glassfacades/facade-structures/glass-fin/.
[5] J. Wurm, “Glass Structures: Design and Construction of Self-supporting Skins”, Springer Science & Business Media, 2007.
[6] Laminated Glass Fins vs. Tempered Monolithic Fins: Guidelines for Point Supported Glass Applications, 2015 [accessed 1.03.2019], Available at: http://www.wwglass.com/blog/post/laminated-glass-fins-vs-tempered-monolithic-glassfins/.
[7] M. Muszynska-Lanowy, “Solar photovoltaic systems”, Swiat Szkla, 3, pp. 10-14, 2011. (in Polish)
[8] R. C. G. M. Loonen, J. M. Rico-Martinez, F. Favoino, M. Brzezicki, Ch. Menezo, G. La Ferla & L. L. Aelenei “Design for façade adaptability: Towards a unified and systematic characterization”. In 10th Conference on Advanced Building Skins, 3-4 November 2015, Bern, Switzerland, pp. 1284-1294, Munich: Economic Forum, 2015.
